Design Briefings
Victoria Bellotti, Apple Computer, Inc., USA
Jakob Nielsen, SunSoft, USA
A design briefing is a presentation of a notable user interface design,
with special emphasis on conceptual issues in the design and on the
design and evaluation methods that were used during its development.
Design briefings are more conceptual and lifecycle-oriented than
demonstrations: presenters do not just show their interface, but also show
preliminary designs and talk about why those designs were modified.
Presenters should include data (or possibly anecdotal evidence) from the
evaluation of the various design iterations, and they may discuss any special
conceptual issues in the system's presentational and interactional
components.
Design briefings are more applied than papers: for example, evaluation data
need not be systematic or statistically significant. Also, the designs need
not necessarily embody fundamental user interface breakthroughs. Even if
similar design ideas have been seen before, a design briefing might still be
accepted if the total user interface integrates these ideas in interesting
ways or if a compelling story can be told about how the design was developed.
Design briefings will be held in an auditorium with 30 minutes for each
presentation (including both a demonstration of the interface and the
conceptual and empirical discussion mentioned above).
Review Process
The Design Briefings committee will consider both product and process
issues for the user interface in question. Thus, submissions will be
evaluated with respect to both how interesting the finished user
interface design is and the extent to which informative stories will be
told about the process of designing the interface. We want interfaces
and design processes that are important and of high quality, but we
also want reports of lessons learned by the designers and lessons for
the audience.
Format
Description.
Prepare an 8-page description of the design briefing in the
Conference Proceedings format.
This description will be published in the
CHI 96 Conference Companion if the design briefing is accepted.
Information that may typically be relevant for a design briefing includes:
-
A statement of why this interface is notable, with screen pictures
(or other illustrations or samples of the interface) pointing out those
major features that will be demonstrated in the design briefing.
-
A list of the major design issues faced during the project with
screen pictures or other illustrations of the preliminary designs.
Discussions of design trade-offs and process innovations are particularly
appropriate.
-
Brief reports on usability evaluation data or anecdotal evidence as to
how both the final design and the preliminary designs work in use.
Additional Information.
Also prepare one or two pages for the design briefings review committee
with information about the presenter's background and involvement in
the actual design project. If several presenters are involved, then all
presenters' backgrounds and project involvement should be described.
Upon Acceptance
Authors will be notified of acceptance or rejection by the end of November
1995. Authors of accepted briefings will then have about one months to revise
their description for publication based on the reviewers' comments.
The 8-page accepted design briefings will be published in the CHI 96
Conference Companion and on the CHI 96 CD-ROM.
The primary author of each accepted design briefing will receive
an Author Kit with detailed instructions on how to submit camera-ready and
electronic materials for publication. These materials are due on
January 5, 1996.
-
Your submission must be in English.
-
Electronic and fax submissions are not accepted.
-
Submissions which arrive after the deadline will not be considered.
-
Your submission should contain no proprietary or confidential material
and should cite no proprietary or confidential publications.
-
Responsibility for permissions to use video, audio or pictures of identifiable
people rests with you, not CHI 96.
-
If your submission is accepted, it will not be published without copyright
release forms signed by the first-listed author or a representative of the
first author's institution.
-
We strongly suggest the use of express mail or a courier service, for
speedy delivery. Customs labels should bear the words "Educational
materials with no commercial value."
Checklist
Please follow the steps in this checklist to ensure completeness in your
submission.
-
Read the Invitation To Submit.
-
Fill out Cover Pages
One,
Two, and
Three
-
Prepare an 8-page
Description
in the
Conference Proceedings format
for publication, as described above.
-
Prepare the
Additional Information
for review, as described above.
-
Collect Cover Pages One, Two and Three, the Description, and the Additional
Information, in the order given, in a packet, and make 10 copies of the packet.
Use 8.5 x 11 inch or A4 paper.
-
Make sure each copy of the packet is STAPLED, not loose or held by clips.
-
You may include a self-addressed reply postcard which will be mailed to
acknowledge receipt of your submission.
-
Send the 10 copies of your submission packet, and the reply postcard, to
the Design Briefings Co-Chair at the
Send To address shown.
chi96-webmaster@acm.org
/ 95-12-01