Social Action Interactive Posters

Reviewers will use this form to document and communicate their evaluation of your Social Action Poster submission. By reviewing this form, you can see the types of things reviewers consider when reading your submission.

CHI 96 Social Action Posters Reviewer's Comments

Poster # ________________       Reviewer # _______________


1.  Please summarize the content in a sentence or phrase:





2.  Does the test describe a topic that is appropriate for social action?

        1) ________   Definitely yes

        2) ________   I think so

        3) ________   Uncertain

        4) ________   Not Really

        5) ________   Not at all
 


Why Not?




3.  Does the text describe a project in sufficient detail so the reader can
    understand what was done?

        1) ________   Definitely yes

        2) ________   I think so

        3) ________   Uncertain

        4) ________   Not Really

        5) ________   Not at all
 


Why Not?



4)  If appropriate, does the text describe outcomes clearly?

        1) ________   Definitely yes

        2) ________   I think so

        3) ________   Uncertain

        4) ________   Not Really

        5) ________   Not at all

        0) _________  Not applicable


Why Not?



5)  Does the text offer information about how readers/viewers can take some 
    action (join, help in other ways, do something similar, obtain
    resources, etc.)?

        1) ________   Definitely yes

        2) ________   I think so

        3) ________   Uncertain

        4) ________   Not Really

        5) ________   Not at all
 


Why Not?


6)  What else is relevant in assessing this work?




7)  DECISION:  Should this poster be accepted into the CHI 96
               Social Action poster program?

        1) ________    Yes, definitely

        2) ________    Yes, probably

        3) ________    Uncertain

        4) ________    No, probably not

        5) ________    No, definitely not


8.  COMMENTS FOR AUTHORS:
    Please write an explanation of your assessment and decision, to be shared
    with the authors: